Bettas do best at 76-81°F and need a heater; goldfish are comfortable at 65-75°F and usually do not. Their ranges barely touch, but size and waste, not the thermostat, are the main reasons the two cannot share a tank.
Some links go to retailers. As an Amazon Associate, Aquarium for Beginners earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
The numbers
| Fish | °F | °C | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| General community tank | 76-78 | 24-26 | The default. Suits tetras, rasboras, corys and livebearers together |
| Betta | 76-81 | 24-27 | Needs a heater. 78-80 is a good target |
| Neon tetra | 70-77 | 21-25 | Happiest at the cool end of a community tank |
| Guppy, molly | 70-82 | 21-28 | Wide range. Guppies cope with cooler water than mollies |
| Platy | 68-79 | 20-26 | Prefers the cooler half of the livebearer range |
| Peppered and bronze corydoras | 72-79 | 22-26 | Sterbai corys are the warm exception, up to 82 |
| Goldfish | 65-75 | 18-24 | Very temperature-tolerant. Usually needs no heater |
| White cloud minnow | 64-72 | 18-22 | Best kept unheated, year-round |
| Cherry shrimp | 72-82 | 22-28 | Bred best at 82 in lab trials. Very warm water stops breeding |
| Discus | 82-86 | 28-30 | Not a beginner fish, and too warm for most of this list |
What temperature should a fish tank be? 76 to 78°F, or 24 to 26°C, for almost every beginner community tank. The Merck Veterinary Manual puts it simply: tropical fish need water kept near 77°F. Set your heater there, check it with a thermometer, and leave it. If you are still choosing one, how aquarium heaters fail, and which to buy covers sizing and the safety features worth paying for.
The table above has the species that want something different. The ranges come from the FishBase and Seriously Fish species profiles, the two standard species databases, and from vet-written care sheets for bettas and goldfish. Two of them matter more than the rest, because they pull in opposite directions.
Why stability matters
Fish are ectothermic: their body temperature is whatever the water's is. Digestion, oxygen use and immune response all run at the speed the water temperature sets, and fish cannot buffer a change.
The University of Florida calls temperature "one of the most important influences on the immune system of fish," and notes that a sharp drop in temperature severely impairs the release of antibodies. The Merck Veterinary Manual adds that fish that survive large temperature swings are at higher risk of bacterial infections afterwards. The University of Florida also notes that ich outbreaks often appear when water temperature is changing quickly.
Not everyone agrees about small daily swings. The Aquarium Science reference argues that, contrary to popular belief, temperature fluctuations do not hurt tropical fish. The evidence is clearest for sudden, large changes, especially drops, and that is what a heater protects against.
What a heater is really for
Not just to make the water warm, but to stop it moving. A room that sits at 74°F in the afternoon and 66°F at 3am is putting your fish through an 8-degree drop every night. The heater's job is to flatten that curve.
The goldfish and betta problem
These are two of the most commonly bought beginner fish, and they pull in opposite directions: the betta a little warmer than a community tank, the goldfish cooler.
A betta does best at 76–81°F, according to PetMD's vet-written care sheet. Wild bettas live in shallow, still water in Southeast Asia, and University of Florida researchers cite one Thai habitat that averaged about 86°F. Their guidance is that bettas "do not do well in cold water." Bettas are sold in unheated cups, which is where the idea that they do not need a heater comes from. A betta in a cool room tends to be sluggish and eat less, and a cold tank is one of the first things to rule out when a betta lies on the bottom. A heater also stops the overnight drop.
A goldfish is comfortable at about 65–75°F and needs no heater in most homes. It is often called a coldwater fish, but it is better described as a very tolerant one: the Southern Regional Aquaculture Center gives a survival range of 32 to 95°F, and in laboratory tests where goldfish could choose their temperature, they settled at around 75–86°F (Coutant, 1977). Cooler water does suit breeding: FishBase says cold winters are necessary for proper egg development, and a 2024 study found goldfish bred better at 72°F than at 82°F. The few fish that suit a goldfish tank are in what fish can live with goldfish.
So the ranges barely meet. Around 75–76°F is the warm edge for a goldfish and the cool edge for a betta. There is a number neither would die at, but none where both are in the middle of their range. And temperature is not even the main obstacle: a goldfish grows far larger and produces far more waste than a betta's gentle, small tank can handle. The full case is in can a betta live with a goldfish.
A goldfish and a betta can survive the same temperature. Neither thrives at it, and size and waste rule the shared tank out before the thermostat does.
Setting your fish tank temperature
- Size the heater at roughly 3–5 watts per gallon, more if the room is cold. Aquarium Co-Op's rule of 5 W per gallon covers heating up to about 10°F above room temperature with a lid on. A 10 gallon wants around 50 W, and a small adjustable heater suits a 5–10 gallon tank.
- Put the heater near the filter outflow, so moving water spreads the heat instead of leaving a warm pocket.
- Put the thermometer at the far end of the tank. Next to the heater it tells you what you want to hear.
- Set it and leave it for 24 hours before adjusting. Heaters respond slowly, and chasing the dial overshoots.
- Do not rely on the dial's printed numbers. Set the heater by what the thermometer actually reads.
- Keep the tank off windowsills and away from exterior walls, radiators and draughts. Placement does more than wattage.
In bigger tanks, two smaller heaters are worth considering instead of one large one. If one fails off, you lose half your heating rather than all of it. If one sticks on, the more dangerous failure, it heats the tank far more slowly than a single large heater would, which buys you time to notice. Aquarium Co-Op makes the same point: smaller heaters reduce the damage a malfunction can do.
When to change it
Rarely, and slowly. PetMD's guidance for goldfish is that the temperature should not move more than about 2°F in 24 hours, and that is a sensible pace for any deliberate change.
The usual reason to raise it is ich. Warm water speeds up the parasite's life cycle: at 75–79°F the University of Florida puts it at about three to six days. That brings the parasite to its free-swimming stage sooner, which is the stage treatments work on. Heat alone is not a cure. Raise the temperature modestly and gradually alongside an ich treatment, and add aeration, because warm water holds less oxygen.
If you are not treating something, leave it alone. A heater that has held 77°F for a year is doing its job, and adjusting it because you read a species chart is a change your fish did not need.
Sources
- Francis-Floyd and Petty. Special Considerations for Fish. Merck Veterinary Manual.
- Francis-Floyd, Yanong and Petty. Environmental Considerations for Selected Infectious Diseases of Aquatic Animals. Merck Veterinary Manual.
- Francis-Floyd. Stress: Its Role in Fish Disease. University of Florida IFAS Extension, FA005.
- Francis-Floyd, Yanong and Pouder. Ichthyophthirius multifiliis (White Spot) Infections in Fish. University of Florida IFAS Extension, FA006.
- Francis-Floyd. Dissolved Oxygen for Fish Production. University of Florida IFAS Extension, FA002.
- Watson, DiMaggio, Hill, Tuckett and Yanong. Evolution, Culture, and Care for Betta splendens. University of Florida IFAS Extension, FA212.
- Zayas. Betta Fish Care Sheet and Witherell. Goldfish Care Sheet. PetMD.
- Watson, Hill and Pouder. Species Profile: Koi and Goldfish. Southern Regional Aquaculture Center, Publication 7201, 2004.
- Coutant. Compilation of Temperature Preference Data. Journal of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 34: 739–745, 1977.
- Taheri-Khas, Gharzi, Vaissi, Heshmatzad and Kalhori. Hormone-Driven Temperature Optimization for Elevated Reproduction in Goldfish (Carassius auratus) under Laboratory Conditions. Animals, 2024.
- Tropea, Stumpf and López Greco. Effect of Temperature on Biochemical Composition, Growth and Reproduction of the Ornamental Red Cherry Shrimp Neocaridina heteropoda heteropoda. PLoS ONE, 2015.
- Aquarium Temperatures. Aquarium Science.
- FishBase and Seriously Fish species profiles for each fish in the table, including Betta splendens, Paracheirodon innesi, Tanichthys albonubes and Carassius auratus.
Questions people ask
Mentioned in this guide
Related guides

Best Aquarium Heater: How Heaters Fail and Which to Buy
The best aquarium heater is right-sized, cuts out when dry and runs on a controller. See how heaters fail and which to buy for 5 to 75 gallon tanks.

Can a Betta Live With a Goldfish? No, and Here's Why
Can a betta live with a goldfish? No. Goldfish need 20 gallons and strong filtration, bettas need calm water, and their temperatures barely overlap.

Best Filter for a 20 Gallon Tank: Picks by Setup, With Specs
The best filter for a 20 gallon tank, long or high: picks for community, goldfish, betta and budget tanks, compared on maker specs and flow.
